E-mail this page E-mail this



Soap Dope

Claim:   A bar of soap between the bedsheets will prevent leg cramps.

UNDETERMINED

Origins:   Many people are plagued by nocturnal leg cramps, those involuntary and agonizing Soap muscle contractions that strike in the depths of the night, waking sleepers with jolts of pain that leave them awash in waves of suffering until the kinks finally relax.

While many possible causes have been posited for these contractions, those afflicted by them are far more concerned with getting rid of these debilitating cramps than they are with understanding their origin. Over the years, many preventions have been suggested, including:
  • Stretching one's calf muscles prior to going to bed.
  • Swearing off caffeine in the evening.
  • Increasing one's intake of potassium, magnesium, calcium or Vitamin E.
  • Sleeping on one's back with toes pointed towards the ceiling.
  • Increasing one's intake of water during the day.
  • Taking quinine (now available only by prescription) or drinking tonic water (which contains small amounts of quinine). It needs be noted that in 2010 the FDA strongly cautioned consumers against using quinine to combat leg cramps because the drug can cause severe side effects, including death.
While all of the above have been said to avert the problem in at least some cases, one further suppression trick appears to work, at least according to anecdotal information, for almost everyone so bedeviled: sleeping with a bar of soap in the bed. No one has yet produced a plausible explanation as to why snoozing with one's Ivory might stave off those devastating nocturnal leg cramps, yet the reports of its doing so are numerous.

Slipping a bar of soap into the bed as a leg cramp prevention has been advanced by a number of authorities, both medical and otherwise. Ann Landers has mentioned the soap cure in her column on a number of occasions, with each airing prompting a load of letters from readers thanking her for this information because it worked wonders for them. "They were thrilled and grateful to be liberated from those leg cramps," said Ms. Landers.

As to how this works — or even if it does — we're still in the dark. Perhaps soap releases something into the air that is beneficial to those
predisposed to this condition, with the bedsheets working to contain the helpful emissions to the area where they are needed. Or perhaps this is a case of believing making it so — the soap itself has no effect, but the sufferer's faith in the procedure serves to effect the miracle.

Yet skepticism aside, for those subject to nocturnal leg cramps, this bit of folk wisdom is clearly worth a try, in that the only potential downside is their having to share their beds with slivers of soap. (Well, that and having their spouses think them a bit loony.) As to what sort of product and where to place it in the bed, although some who pass along this bit of housewifely lore indicate specifics such as the soap's having to be unwrapped or not be a specific brand (Dial and Dove are often mentioned as bars to eschew), those who swear by the procedure have had success whether they used large bars or the small ones commonly found in hotel rooms, whether the cakes of soap were wrapped or unwrapped, and whether the afflicted leg was rested on top of the soap or not. As for which brand is best, cautions against Dove and Dial to the contrary, they all seem to work about the same.

Regarding what to do about an existing leg cramp, folk wisdom once again offers a variety of potential answers:
  • Ingest a teaspoon of yellow mustard.
  • Drink a glass of water that has a quarter of a teaspoon of baking soda mixed into it.
  • Pour salt into your hand and lick it.
  • Pinch the skin between the nose and the upper lip.
Barbara "cramp stamp" Mikkelson

Last updated:   21 August 2011

Urban Legends Reference Pages © 1995-2014 by snopes.com.
This material may not be reproduced without permission.
snopes and the snopes.com logo are registered service marks of snopes.com.

Sources:

    Donohue, Paul.   "Not All Hepatitis C Patients Need Treatment."
    [Passaic County] Herald News.   18 February 2005   (p. D17).

    Donohue, Paul.   "Readers Provide Remedies for Muscle Cramps."
    Chattanooga Times Free Press.   23 January 2004   (p. E4).

    Gott, Peter.   "Moderate Vitamin Intake Is OK."
    Ventura County Star.   24 May 2005   (p. 6).

    Gott, Peter.   "Soap Remedy for Leg Cramps Again at the Forefront."
    Tulsa World.   18 February 2005   (p. D4).

    Gott, Peter.   "Report of Soap to Treat Leg Cramps Holds Water."
    Tulsa World.   1 March 2005   (p. D2).

    Graedon, Joe and Teresa.   "Nitroglycerin Tablets Could Set Off Alarm at Airport."
    The Baltimore Sun.   20 March 2005   (p. N7).

    Maugh, Thomas.   "The FDA Warns Against Using Quinine For Leg Cramps."
    Los Angeles Times .   8 July 2010.