Old Wives' Tales
Radio & TV
Toxin du jour
Claim: Illegitimate child grows up to become Governor of Tennessee.
Example: [Collected on the Internet, 2002]
Origins: We began seeing this "Who's Your Daddy?" tale on the Internet in late 2002. Some versions of the story attribute it to
While what circulates online was not penned by
While young Ben Hooper (described in Craddock's account as in his "early teens," rather than the
When I went into town with her [his mother], I could see people staring at me, making guesses as to who was my father. At school, the children said ugly things to me, and so I stayed to myself during recess, and I ate lunch alone.The biggest difference lies in how the encounter with the new minister is described. While the online version has the minister accosting Hooper with "Son, who's your daddy?" and the rest of the congregation listening in, Craddock's account of what Hooper said has the minister thinking but not posing the question, with no mention of parishioners hanging on his every word or even observing the exchange:
One Sunday some people queued up in the aisle before I could get out, and I was stopped. Before I could make my way through the group, I felt a hand on my shoulder, a heavy hand. It was that minister. I cut my eyes around and caught a glimpse of his beard and his chin, and I knew who it was. I trembled in fear. He turned his face around so he could see mine and seemed to be staring for a little while. I knew what he was doing. He was going to make a guess as to who my father was. A moment later he said, "Well, boy, you're a child of..." and he paused there. And I knew it was coming. I knew I would have my feelings hurt. I knew I would not go back again! He said, "Boy, you're a child of God. I see a striking resemblance, boy." Then he swatted me on the bottom and said, "Now, you go claim your inheritance." I left the building a different person. In fact, that was really the beginning of my life.As is sometimes the case with glurge pieces, this one is a mix of truth and fabrication. Neither the
Ben W. Hooper (1870-1957), the governor of Tennessee from 1911 to 1915, was born out of wedlock in Newport, Tennessee, on
Soon after Bennie's birth, Sarah's father moved the family to another town. Through the age of eight the boy lived in a number of small towns in Tennessee while his mother looked for work, but upon the death of her father he was placed in a Knoxville orphanage, an act that rescued Bennie from a life of dire poverty.
Dr. Hooper came to hear that his son was being kept in that institution and sought him out. The doctor had since married his fianceé, but the couple remained childless, their one previous attempt to raise a son having been thwarted by the death of the baby they'd taken on. About a year after he'd been brought to the orphanage, Bennie was adopted by the Hoopers and fetched back to Newport.
Back in Bennie's hometown, the local children quickly acquainted him with the facts of his birth. Unlike the child in the "Who's Your Daddy?" piece quoted above, the real Ben Hooper did not slink from the taunts of classmates — he readily answered their insults with his fists. As to the effect the news of his bastardy had upon him, Ben Hooper later said, "Instead of my supposed handicap generating an inferiority complex, it motivated a spirit of ambition and determination that furnished the impetus to carry me over many a hill in my young days. I began to understand that sensible people might appraise a man upon his character and attainments rather than upon the accident of birth or the merits of his antecedents. This possibility furnished a great incentive to effort."
And effort he made. Ben attended public schools, graduated from Carson-Newman College in 1890, became a lawyer, entered the world of politics, and eventually rose to the office of governor of Tennessee.
The premise of "Who's Your Daddy?" is flawed in that young Ben Hooper did not need any preacher to tell him he was a child of God. Long before adults told him any different, young Ben had worked out that it was the merits of what he would do in this world that would matter to anyone worth bothering with, not how he'd come to be here. Ben was no shy boy trudging through life with his head bowed in meek submission; he was a lad determined to be the best in his class in defiance of his detractors. Likewise, his paternity wasn't in doubt, so there would not have been a churchful of judgmental townsfolk just waiting for the kid to finally blurt out the name of his father. Bennie had been known as the doctor's son from the time of his birth, so when
Bennie did attend the Baptist church in Newport during his childhood, and after a couple of years he became that institution's janitor (for the sum of fifty cents a month). His autobiography is silent on the subject of preachers during this period in his life, let alone preachers who proclaimed him as a child of God to a cruel congregation and thereby supplied him with a pithy answer to hurl back at his tormentors. Bennie was baptized into the faith at age 15 and remained a staunch Baptist throughout his life.
Like we said, it's a mixture of fact and fiction. The salient point — that a boy born out of wedlock went on to serve as Governor of Tennessee — more than holds up to scrutiny. Yet the glurgerrific part — that the child established his sense of himself only thanks to a preacher's public branding of him as a "child of God" — founders against the rock of Ben Hooper's autobiography. There was no such preacher, and from Ben's account of his early days, there would have been no need for one.
Interestingly enough, the "Who's Your Daddy?" piece contains the counterpart to an element found in a widespread urban legend:
As the man turned to leave, he said, "You know, if that new preacher hadn't told me that I was one of God's children, I probably never would have amounted to anything!" And he walked away.The legend sometimes called the "Bookkeeper in a Brothel" (but we call it "Reading Railroaded") keys on a theme of a rebuff's leading to success. A fellow who applies for a bookkeeper's job in a bordello is turned down because he can't read, and it's this setback that paves the way for his ultimate success. The story culminates in the lucky fellow's amazed assessment that if he hadn't been illiterate, all he'd have amounted to would have been a bookkeeper in a whorehouse rather than the very rich entrepreneur he did in fact become.
It's possible this somewhat shared element contains the key to the "Who's Your Daddy?" tale. The repositioning of the real Ben Hooper story into one about a weak-kneed boy and the man of God who armed him with a sense of himself and a ready answer for his detractors attempts to lay credit for Hooper's success at quite a different pair of feet.
Barbara "baring false witness" Mikkelson
Last updated: 23 August 2008
This material may not be reproduced without permission.
snopes and the snopes.com logo are registered service marks of snopes.com.